Stratigraphy and compositional evolution of Cinder Cone, a composite monogenetic cone in Lassen Volcanic National Park, California

Clynne, Michael

Cinder Cone, in Lassen Volcanic National Park, has received considerable attention in the literature since its description by Harkness (1875) and Diller (1891) and has provoked considerable controversy concerning its age and eruptive history (e.g. Finch and Anderson, 1930; Finch, 1937). Geologic mapping of the composite cinder cone, an extensive tephra blanket, and 5 lava flows determined the eruptive sequence stratigraphy (Clynne and Muffler, 2010), and tree-ring chronology dated the eruption as 1666 C.E. (Sheppard et al., 2008). Tephra, divided into 3 units by Heiken (1978), accounts for 20% of the 0.36 km3 total volume of the eruption. The lava field consists of 5 block lava flows: Old Bench (OB), Painted Dunes (PD) 1 and 2, and Fantastic Lava Beds (FL) 1 and 2. Magnesian olivine containing inclusions of chromian spinel is the most abundant phenocryst, followed by plagioclase and sparse augite. Xenocrystic quartz is ubiquitous. Three types of inclusions are present: 1) sparse, mostly melted, inclusions of granitic rocks derived from Sierran basement, 2) abundant single crystals of quartz derived from granitic rocks and multicrystalline inclusions of metamorphic quartz from veins, and 3) rare magmatic enclaves of olivine basalt with quenched textures. The tephra and OB, PD, and FL lithologies are olivine basaltic andesite to andesite with subtle differences. Analyses of tephra from a measured section document the compositional evolution of Cinder Cone eruption. Unit 1 tephra contains 55.5% SiO2, 7.9% MgO, and 1.25% K2O. Initial unit 2 tephra contains 54.8% SiO2, 8.2% MgO, and 1.2% K2O. Unit 2 tephra becomes increasing more mafic up section to 53.8% SiO2, 9.0% MgO, and 1.0% K2O and then rapidly more felsic to 56.3% SiO2, 8.0% MgO, and 1.3% K2O. Initial unit 3 tephra contains 58.0% SiO2, 7.5% MgO, and 1.6% K2O but becomes more mafic to 55.0% SiO2, 7.5% MgO, and 1.2% K2O up section. The OB flow and the early PD 1 flow are equivalent in composition to the early unit 2 tephra, and the subsequent late PD 1 flow and PD 2 flows mimic late unit 2 tephra. FL 1 and 2 flows are compositionally equivalent to early and late unit 3 tephra, respectively. A mostly destroyed remnant cinder cone has unit 2 tephra composition, and Cinder Cone has unit 3 composition. The complex compositional variation at Cinder Cone, superficially a monogenetic volcano, is ascribed to the combined effects of fractional crystallization and assimilation and concurrent recharge of the system by a new mafic magma. Variation of the early magmas can be modeled by fractional crystallization and assimilation of granitic xenoliths. The reversal of compositional variation near the unit 2-3 boundary and subsequent decrease in SiO2 can be modeled by mixing with a new mafic magma having the composition of the quenched basaltic enclaves. Details of the mineral compositions are consistent with the stratigraphy and bulk compositional evolution.