Monitoring Rocky Intertidal Communities in the San Francisco Bay Area Network: 2006–2024 Status and Trends Synthesis Report

Raimondi PT , Miner CM , Gaddam R, Becker B, Fong D, Lee SF. 2025. Monitoring Rocky Intertidal Communities in the San Francisco Bay Area Network: 2006–2024 Status and Trends Synthesis Report. Science Report. NPS/SR—2026/528. National Park Service. Fort Collins, Colorado. https://doi.org/10.36967/2318604

Rocky intertidal monitoring within the San Francisco Bay Area Network (SFAN) is led by scientists at Golden Gate National Recreation Area (GOGA) and Point Reyes National Seashore (PORE) and includes four outer coast sites and one site within San Francisco Bay on Alcatraz Island. These sites encompass a broad range of physical conditions that shape rocky intertidal communities and include both relatively pristine and heavily visited areas. To conserve these communities unimpaired for future generations, the NPS has been monitoring focal species assemblages since as early as 1989. Percent cover data are collected for barnacles, mussels, two rockweed species, two red algae species, and surfgrass. Ochre stars are counted, sized, and assessed for disease. Monitoring protocols are consistent with those used by the Multi-Agency Rocky Intertidal Network (MARINe), a collaborative effort that includes all west coast NPS networks. Using this approach enables scaling of trend comparisons, from within-park to the entire U.S. west coast, and thus greatly expands the utility of the data. Key SFAN monitoring objectives include characterizing natural variation and detecting trends in focal species abundance and community structure. Trends for focal species are summarized in this report for data collected between 2006 and 2024. Long-term trends were generally stable for long-lived species such as the California mussel, while year-to-year changes in percent cover or abundance were more variable for shorter-lived species, such as acorn barnacles and rockweeds. Ochre stars declined over time at most SFAN sites—a pattern that was exacerbated by a disease outbreak in 2014–2015. Power analyses revealed generally high power to detect a 40% change in abundance of focal species in many cases, but at some sites power was insufficient for detecting this relatively high level of change. By contrast, similar analyses done at the whole-community level revealed high power to detect much lower levels of change at most sites. This whole-community-level approach is likely the more appropriate metric for assessing change in many cases. We also examined temporal patterns in community similarity at sites using non-metric multidimensional scaling. Results highlighted differences in community structure among sites and patterns of change over time and provided insight into the species driving these patterns. In general, SFAN monitoring goals are being addressed well by using the MARINe survey approach. These data are key for making informed decisions about managing and preserving rocky intertidal habitats within the SFAN.

Type
Published Report
Authors
Raimondi, Peter; Miner, C.; Gaddam, Rani; Becker, Benjamin; Fong, Darren; Lee, Steven
Date of Issue
2025-11
Publisher
National Park Service
DOI
10.36967/2318604
Units
GOGA , NRSS , PORE , SFAN
Keywords
acorn barnacle, Balanus glandula, California mussel, Chthamalus dalli/fissus, community similarity, Endocladia muricata, long-term monitoring, Mastocarpus spp., Mytilus californianus, ochre star, Phyllospadix scouleri/torreyi, Pisaster ochraceus, Rocky Intertidal, surfgrass, temperate rocky intertidal, turfweed, Turkish washcloth

Series

Browse the catalog