Evaluating Metabarcoding of Wildflower Associated eDNA to Assess Butterfly Presence and Abundance
Farout-Daniels C, Debinski DM, Flenniken ML . 2026. Evaluating Metabarcoding of Wildflower Associated eDNA to Assess Butterfly Presence and Abundance. Ecology and Evolution. 16(11):1-14
Rapid and accurate assessment of insect communities is increasingly important in the context of climate change and biodiversity loss. Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis has proven useful as a noninvasive method for detecting insects in aquatic systems, and methods for terrestrial eDNA sources are being developed. Analysis of wildflower-associated DNA may be useful for identifying insect pollinators. This study paired traditional butterfly netting surveys in a montane protected area with wildflower-associated eDNA metabarcoding to test whether the presence and abundance of butterfly species can be accurately assessed. Specifically, Lepidoptera targeting primers were used to amplify two regions of the cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI) gene from wildflower-associated eDNA samples. Analysis of the ~350 million sequences obtained identified ~94% as insects, with ~23% assigned to Lepidoptera. Six butterfly taxa, including four at the species level, were identified, including five that were consistent with species captured during netting surveys conducted in parallel. However, butterfly detections from eDNA did not correspond with either contrived or natural flower visitation, and traditional surveys identified 44 butterfly species not captured by eDNA. The most prevalently detected taxa were small-bodied insects closely associated with flowers. Together our results indicate that additional refinement of protocols and primers is needed before wildflower-associated eDNA can reliably survey butterfly species.
- Type
- Journal Article
- Authors
- Farout-Daniels, Cayley; Debinski, Diane; Flenniken, Michelle
- Units
- CRCO , GLAC
- Keywords
- butterflies, eDNA, environmental DNA, metabarcoding, wildflowers
- License
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International